It is much hotter and If this is your first time, please protect yourself from potential allergies. Homemade Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce Recipe. Over medium heat saute garlic and shallots for a about 1 minute or until light brown and fragrant. Set 8 ounces of Carolina Reaper peppers, 1 heat of garlic (top slices off) and halved onion on … Fry the garlic and shallots enough so that they become crispy, but not burnt. Ingredients for the sauce: 6-8 Carolina Reaper peppers; 1 cup vinegar of choice; ½ cup olive oil; Pink Himalayan salt to taste; 1 garlic clove, crushed; ¼ onion, finely chopped Add fish sauce, vinegar, and sugar. Do not take this hot sauce for granted, nor compare it to other sauces. Let the sauce come to a simmer then lower heat to keep at a low simmer. 2.Add tomato sauce and finely chopped carolina reaper chili peppers. First, heat your oven to 400 degrees.